Future of Work
3 min read

AI vs. The Trades: Why Your Plumber Might Have Better Job Security Than Your Accountant

As artificial intelligence reshapes the workforce, many fear for their jobs. This article explores why skilled trades like plumbing and carpentry may be surprisingly resilient to automation compared to many white-collar professions.

AI vs. The Trades: Why Your Plumber Might Have Better Job Security Than Your Accountant

We've all seen the headlines: AI is coming for our jobs. For years, the narrative has been that robots would replace blue-collar workers on assembly lines. But the recent explosion of generative AI has flipped the script. Suddenly, it's writers, analysts, and even coders who are feeling the heat. Amidst this uncertainty, a surprising group of professionals is emerging as one of the most secure: skilled trade workers.

The Great AI Misconception

For a long time, we believed that jobs requiring higher education were the safest bet. The thinking was that complex, knowledge-based work was uniquely human. However, large language models (LLMs) and other AI systems are exceptionally good at processing information, identifying patterns, and generating content—the very essence of many office jobs.

An AI can analyze a spreadsheet in seconds, draft a legal document, or write marketing copy. What it can't do is navigate the cramped, unpredictable space under your sink to fix a leaking pipe. It can't rewire a historic home while adapting to unforeseen structural issues, nor can it feel the subtle tension in a bolt that indicates it's perfectly tightened.

Why Skilled Trades are Uniquely Human

The resilience of skilled trades lies in their connection to the physical world. These jobs require a blend of skills that are incredibly difficult for AI to replicate:

  • Complex Manual Dexterity: Think of an electrician carefully threading wires through a conduit or a carpenter making a precise cut. These tasks require fine motor skills and a tactile understanding of materials that are far beyond current robotic capabilities.
  • Dynamic Problem-Solving: No two job sites are the same. A plumber might encounter ancient pipes, an HVAC technician might have to diagnose a bizarre rattling sound, and a welder might need to adapt a technique for a custom fabrication. They solve unique, real-world puzzles every day.
  • Unstructured Environments: AI thrives in predictable, digital environments. The physical world is messy and chaotic. A robot can't easily climb a ladder, navigate a cluttered basement, or work safely on a sloped roof in changing weather conditions.

AI: The Ultimate Tool, Not a Replacement

This doesn't mean AI will have no impact on the trades. On the contrary, it's poised to become an incredibly powerful tool. Imagine an electrician using an AI-powered app to instantly diagnose a complex wiring issue, or a construction manager using AI to optimize schedules and enhance worksite safety.

AI can handle the administrative and diagnostic parts of the job, freeing up skilled professionals to do what they do best: apply their hands-on expertise to solve physical problems. The tradesperson of the future will likely be a tech-savvy expert, using AI to work smarter, faster, and safer.

Key Takeaways for Your Career

As you think about career longevity in the age of AI, consider the unique value of skilled trades. The demand for qualified electricians, plumbers, welders, and mechanics is already high, and it's only projected to grow.

Here are the key points to remember:

  1. AI Excels at Digital Tasks: AI is better at automating predictable, data-driven office work than complex, physical labor.
  2. The Physical World is AI's Weakness: Skilled trades operate in unstructured, real-world environments that are a major challenge for automation.
  3. Human Skills Remain Crucial: Manual dexterity, on-the-fly problem-solving, and adaptability are skills that give tradespeople a distinct advantage.
  4. AI Will Be a Co-pilot: Technology will augment, not replace, skilled workers, making them more efficient and effective.
  5. Job Security is Shifting: The future of work may value a skilled hand just as much, if not more, than a desk-bound analyst.
Source article for inspiration